Search Publica

Politics

Electoral maps go back to court after a decade of drift

Population shifts have left some constituencies with twice the voters of others, and with the boundary commission's review stalled, opposition parties are asking judges to step in.

2 min read

An empty wood-panelled courtroom with a large mural above the judges' bench
An empty wood-panelled courtroom with a large mural above the judges' benchPhoto: Carol M. Highsmith / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The last time the country’s parliamentary boundaries were redrawn, the capital’s newest suburbs were still farmland. A decade of migration from the countryside to the cities has left the electoral map badly out of shape. The largest constituency now has more than twice as many registered voters as the smallest, and the gap widens every year.

Next week, the constitutional court will hear a challenge brought by three opposition parties, who argue that the imbalance violates the principle of equal suffrage. It is the first case of its kind in more than twenty years, and its outcome could reshape the next general election.

How the map drifted

By law, an independent boundary commission must review constituencies every eight years and propose new lines that keep each seat within ten per cent of the national average. The last review was due three years ago. It was delayed first by a dispute over which census figures to use, and then by a parliamentary vote, backed by the governing coalition, to postpone it until after the next election.

The effect is uneven. Fast-growing urban and suburban seats, which tend to favour the opposition, are now heavily oversized. Rural constituencies, many held by governing parties, have shrunk.

The challengers make two claims: that the current boundaries breach the constitution’s guarantee of equal votes, and that parliament acted unlawfully when it postponed the review. They are asking the court to order the commission to complete its work in time for the next election or, failing that, to set interim boundaries itself.

The government argues that the constitution sets no precise tolerance, and that drawing lines is a matter for parliament rather than judges. A constitutional lawyer who has advised past commissions described the dilemma facing the court.

Judges hate drawing maps. They hate unequal votes more.

What the court could do

The options open to the bench, according to legal analysts, range from a declaration with no immediate effect to a firm deadline backed by the threat of court-drawn boundaries. Most expect something in between: a ruling that the delay was unlawful, and a timetable giving the commission around a year to finish.

What happens next

Hearings are scheduled over three days, with a judgment expected before the end of the year. If the court orders a new review, the commission has said it can produce provisional proposals within six months, followed by public consultation. Party organisers are already studying which seats would vanish, and which sitting members might find themselves competing for the same new constituency.

Share this story