Search Publica

Business

App store rules are being rewritten by regulators, not platforms

Competition authorities on three continents are forcing changes to payment terms, commission rates and sideloading, and developers are discovering that compliance does not always mean cheaper.

2 min read

A finger tapping the screen of a smartphone lying on a white table beside a green apple
A finger tapping the screen of a smartphone lying on a white table beside a green applePhoto: Unknown author / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

For more than a decade, the rules governing how software reaches a smartphone were written by the companies that make the phones. Commission rates, payment systems, review procedures and the question of whether apps could be installed from anywhere else were set in private terms of service and changed at will. That era is ending, not because the platforms chose to change, but because regulators have made them.

Competition authorities in several large markets have now adopted or proposed rules that require the dominant mobile platforms to allow alternative payment systems, reduce or justify their commissions, and permit apps to be distributed outside the official stores. The effect on developers is real, but not always what they expected.

What regulators have required

The new rules vary by jurisdiction, but most share three elements:

  • developers must be allowed to offer payment methods other than the platform’s own;
  • platforms must allow, or at least not obstruct, distribution through alternative stores or direct download;
  • anti-steering clauses that stopped apps from telling users about cheaper prices elsewhere are banned.

The fine print of compliance

The platforms have complied, but on their own terms. In several markets, developers who use alternative payments still owe a reduced commission, along with new fees for processing and security review. Some smaller studios have calculated that, after the new charges, their costs barely change, and a few have found them higher.

A competition economist who advises one national regulator described the pattern as predictable.

Every rule we write becomes a new fee schedule within a quarter.

Regulators have responded by opening formal reviews of the compliance plans, and one authority has signalled that it may set a ceiling on total charges rather than regulate each fee separately.

Who benefits

Large developers with millions of subscribers have gained the most: they can afford their own payment systems and can steer users towards cheaper web purchases. Smaller developers face a harder choice, because running their own billing brings costs of its own, from fraud management to customer support, that the platform previously absorbed.

Consumer groups welcome the changes but warn of new risks. Apps installed outside official stores bypass review, and security researchers have already documented imitation apps distributed through unofficial channels.

What happens next

Further decisions are due within the year, including rulings on whether the platforms’ revised fees comply with the law. Trade negotiators are also watching closely: some governments have argued that national rules on app stores amount to barriers to digital trade. For developers, the immediate lesson is that the terms of distribution are now set in two places, and both need reading carefully.

Share this story