Energy ministers draw up a winter plan nobody wanted to need
Storage targets, a shared demand-reduction pledge and an emergency gas-sharing mechanism were agreed after a fourteen-hour session that left the hardest question, who pays, for autumn.

The meeting was scheduled for six hours and ran to fourteen. When energy ministers finally emerged shortly before two in the morning, they had agreed a plan for the coming winter that every one of them hoped would remain on paper.
Supplies are not currently short. Storage sites are filling at roughly the normal rate, and spot prices have been stable since March. But two pipeline routes remain under maintenance into the autumn, and forecasters give a cold, windless January about a one-in-five chance. The plan is insurance against that January.
What was agreed
The core of the package is three commitments:
- fill gas storage to ninety per cent of capacity by the first of November
- cut collective gas demand by ten per cent against the five-year average if an alert is declared
- share supplies across borders automatically once any member’s storage falls below a set threshold
The first is already within reach for most countries. The second is voluntary until an alert is declared, at which point it becomes binding. The third is the most significant: for the first time, governments have agreed in advance to send gas to a neighbour before their own households are fully covered.
The sticking point
What ministers could not agree was who pays when gas moves. A country sending supplies abroad during an emergency may have to buy replacement volumes at peak prices, and several delegations insisted that the receiving country should compensate them in full, at the market rate on the day of transfer.
Solidarity is easy to sign at midnight. It is harder to invoice in January.
That was how one diplomat described the final hours of the session. Smaller importing countries argued that full market compensation during a crisis would make the mechanism unaffordable for precisely the members most likely to need it.
What happens next
A working group of officials has until the end of September to propose a compensation formula. The options under discussion range from a fixed price cap on emergency transfers to a shared fund, paid into in advance by all members according to the size of their economies.
Neither will be easy to agree. But officials point out that the hardest part, the principle that gas will move across borders in an emergency, has now been signed. The plan nobody wanted to need is at least, for the first time, a plan.







